Who doesn’t love a snack? Whether it’s some carrot sticks or a chocolate biscuit (TimTam anyone?) I’m sure many/most of us are partial to a snack.
But how about ‘snacking’ on ‘bites’ of exercise instead? The concept of activity ‘snacks’ was discussed in an editorial in this months BJGP and it really chimed with me. So what are activity snacks, and could they be a strategy to help people struggling to get their daily exercise, get a bit more active?
Lack of physical activity remains one of the biggest modifiable risk factors for poor physical and mental health. So why is exercise, identified by the Academy of Medical Royal Colleges over 10 years ago as a ‘Miracle Cure’, so difficult to promote in General Practice and embed in peoples’ day to day lives? I’m sure we’ll all be aware of the multiple reasons for this - lack of time, low motivation, financial barriers and many more. And that’s just our patients….I’m sure all of us would stick our hand up and accept there are many consultations where ideally we should spend more time promoting exercise, but we also face barriers - time constraints and the worry our patient will disengage when we start banging on about lifestyle measures again. You see the eyes glaze over as we trot out the NHS advice to ‘do at least 150 minutes of moderate intensity activity a week’ as your patient considers which world you actually come from….It can depressing for them and us.
As the BJGP sums up ‘There is a clear need to explore ways of promoting physical activity, beyond mere advice, that are efficient within the constraints of general practice’. So could activity ‘snacks’ help us here?
Activity snacks - I’m hungry to hear more
Activity snacks are short (2-5 minute) periods of moderate intensity activity that can be done throughout the day, rather than in one go, with the aim that they become habitual. Examples might include doing calf raises while brushing your teeth, walking while using the phone instead of sitting down, doing lunges while watching telly, carrying bags when shopping rather than using a shopping trolley, doing bicep curls with a bottle while seated, or getting off the bus one stop early and walking the rest - basically anything that can get your heart rate up for a couple of minutes and (ideally) get you a bit breathless. Although even shorter bouts can help - the focus is as much to reduce sedentary time as it is to increase activity time, both of which are associated with improved health outcomes.
Importantly they are practical, require no extra kit or expense, and are manageable. Ultimately the aim is to do activity ‘snacks’ 8-10 times per day, but starting doing these 1-2 times per day should be achievable for everyone, and by building in more ‘snacks’ over time you can very quickly get to that 150 minutes/week mark.
Do activity snacks work?
We have to be honest that this is early days, and whether this is something that will be effective to promote in General Practice we don’t know yet; but a recent meta-analysis of 11 RCTs found moderate certainty evidence that activity snacks improved cardiorespiratory fitness in physically inactive adults, alongside lower certainty evidence they improve muscular endurance in older adults. Alongside this qualitative evidence has shown this is a strategy that was welcomed by both patients and healthcare professionals.
An opportunity to practice what we preach
And this is obviously something we can consider doing in our days as GPs. How many times do you get to the end of the day feeling like you’ve been welded to your chair for 10 hours? I think we can forget sometimes the power of us ‘practicing what we preach’ to help influence positive behaviours in our patients.
The importance of a short walk
So what am I doing? Well, for what it’s worth my activity snacks are walking to and from the waiting room to get my patients. I disconnected the call system to my room having read a great article in the BJGP some years ago (Consultations start in the waiting room). 8 years down the line I’m still doing my short walks, and I'm still seeing the benefits - alongside the benefits of more walking/less sitting it gives me a moment to ‘draw breath’ between consultations, observe my patients getting up and out of the chair in the waiting room (helpful for that frailty assessment…), gives us a chance to get the ‘weather discussion’ out of the way, and gives some gentle observable health promotion.… ‘Is the call system not working Doc?’. ‘Nope, I had it disconnected to get me out of my chair and increase my steps, stretch my legs, I really find it helps.’ Occasionally the penny will then drop.

You can quickly add CPD to your account by writing a reflective note about the Activity Snacks post you've read.
Log in to your NB Dashboard and use the 'Add Reflective Note' button at the bottom of a blog entry to add your note.